Introducing critical speed
The line between the paces you can hold and the ones you can't, and why it should shape your training.
Contents9 sections
Have you ever wondered why you can maintain your 10km pace for much longer than your 5km pace? Or why some runners seem to excel at shorter, high-intensity efforts while others dominate the longer distances? The answer lies in a piece of exercise physiology called critical speed. There’s a lot to it, so I’ve split it into a series:
- What is critical speed? (this post)
- What’s the physiology behind the model?
- How do you calculate it?
- How do you use it in training?
- What are the model’s trade-offs?
- What other models sit alongside it?
- How do you estimate critical speed from race finish times?
- How do you build a critical speed model from your everyday running data?
Summary
Critical speed (CS) is the fastest pace you can run while your body stays in a metabolic steady state. Below it, you can keep going for a long time; above it, the clock is ticking. It usually falls between your 10km and 5km pace. If you had to guess your critical speed right now, it would likely be a few percent slower than your current 5km pace1 Percentages work on time per kilometre, as in Renato Canova-style training. 5% slower than 3:30/km is seconds, or about 3:40/km., but certainly faster than what you’d consider your “comfortably hard” threshold pace.
What makes critical speed so valuable is its practicality. Unlike lactate threshold testing, which requires blood draws and specialised equipment which is not always as accurate as you would hope, critical speed can be calculated from your regular training data or race performances. It’s a performance-based metric that’s deeply grounded in physiology, making it more reliable than many other training metrics that rely on arbitrary percentages or generic formulas.
I’m interested in critical speed because I want to use it as the basis for personalised performance models calibrated with day-to-day training data.
What is critical power?
Before we dive into critical speed, we need to understand its older sibling: critical power. The concept was first introduced in a paper2 The paper can be found here and is worth a read. It’s only within the last 15 years or so that the critical power model has come to the fore. back in 1965 by Monod and Scherrer, who investigated the relationship between the maximum amount of muscular work that could be performed for various lengths of time. This foundational research laid the groundwork for our modern understanding of how energy systems interact during sustained exercise.
Critical power is one way to estimate what exercise physiologists call the maximal metabolic steady state, or MMSS — the true physiological boundary which separates stable and unstable metabolic states. While MMSS is the actual physiological parameter we’re trying to measure, critical power is just one of several methods we can use to estimate it. Other estimation methods include the lactate threshold3 There are two lactate thresholds. The one that sits near MMSS is the second (LT2, sometimes called the anaerobic threshold). The first, LT1, is lower: roughly the top of genuinely easy running. and maximal lactate steady state (MLSS). Think of MMSS as the “true” boundary we’re trying to find, and critical power as one of the tools we use to locate it.
The reason why I’m writing a whole article series on critical speed and not the lactate threshold or MLSS is because critical speed is considered the best way to estimate MMSS. From the linked paper abstract:
CP represents the genuine boundary separating exercise in which physiological homeostasis can be maintained from exercise in which it cannot, and should be considered the gold standard when the goal is to determine the maximal metabolic steady state.
In a lab, you’d find critical power by measuring oxygen consumption. Cyclists have a cheaper option: a power meter measures the mechanical power at the pedals, which tracks metabolic power closely. Plot your best average power for every duration and you get a power-duration curve that approximates your critical power curve.
What is critical speed?
Enough of cycling. While they had power meters to quantify their efforts, runners were left without an equivalent tool. Running power meters exist4 Stryd is probably the best known., but they’re essentially sophisticated guesswork — using accelerometers, gyroscopes, and algorithms to estimate what power might look like for running. The reality is that there’s no true equivalent to the mechanical power measurement available in cycling.
This is where critical speed comes in. Instead of trying to measure power, we use speed as our proxy for intensity. Like critical power, critical speed creates a clear boundary between running speeds that can be maintained in a metabolically steady state and those that cannot. It’s intuitive when you think about it. You can maintain your half-marathon pace much longer than your 1500m pace, and this relationship follows predictable physiological principles.
In practical training terms, critical speed serves as the boundary between training zones 3 and 45 Though in most training zone schemes which use lactate threshold as the 3-4 boundary, critical speed would likely sit within the lower section of zone 4. in a typical 5 zone system and represents an intensity that most athletes can maintain for about 15 to 30 minutes.
The variability in this duration range is actually quite revealing — it exists because (as mentioned above) critical speed is an estimate of your true MMSS, not the parameter itself. This variability has important implications. If you underestimate your critical speed, you’ll find you can maintain it for longer periods than expected. Overestimate it, and you’ll fade much quicker than anticipated. Hence the reported variability6 In the post on estimating critical speed from race times, I’ll use the powerof10 dataset to show how closely a 5km time pins it down.. There’s also the concept of durability which comes into play, where speed falls over time (and at different rates depending on the athlete) despite a constant metabolic effort.
The model
The critical speed model defines a hyperbolic7 Speed above CS multiplied by the time you can hold it is always the same: . Two quantities whose product is constant trace a hyperbola. relationship between the maximum speed you can maintain for any running duration. As speed increases, duration must decrease, and this relationship follows a predictable mathematical pattern:
Where is running speed, and is the “time limit” you can sustain a given speed. and are two parameters that vary from one runner to another, and which can change as your fitness level increases or declines.
The first parameter, (measured in metres per second), is the asymptote that the curve approaches and represents the boundary between sustainable and unsustainable paces. Viewing critical speed as a boundary is crucial. It’s not a pace you should train at. If you try to run at critical speed then you are likely to get unpredictable results.
The second parameter, (pronounced “D prime”), is where things get interesting. It’s measured in metres, which might seem odd at first, but there’s a sensible reason for this. represents the actual distance you can cover using your anaerobic energy system during an all-out effort before you need to stop due to exhaustion. Think of it as your finite energy reserve. The extra distance you can travel even after you’ve reached the limits of your aerobic system and hit VO2max.
Recent research by Burnley (2023) has shown that is remarkably consistent across different types of exercise, suggesting it represents a fundamental physiological limit rather than just a mathematical parameter. This makes the model even more powerful as a training tool.
When you’re running at maximum effort, you’re not just using your anaerobic system in isolation — your aerobic system is working at (or near to) its maximum capacity. The model encapsulates both systems working together, with representing that extra metabolic power you can access even after you’ve reached VO2max and your muscles are using anaerobic processes to produce ATP.
If you run at a pace just slightly above your critical speed, that finite energy reserve gets spread out over a longer duration. Run much faster, and you burn through it quickly, which is why very high speeds can only be maintained for short periods.
Visualising critical speed
Take a moment to play around with the graph below. You can adjust both the CS (critical speed) and D’ (anaerobic capacity) parameters to see how they affect the speed-duration curve, and the length of an effort to see the speed and pace the model gives for it.
When you increase the critical speed slider, notice how the entire curve shifts upward, giving you a higher “floor” from which to base your anaerobic efforts. This represents having better aerobic fitness — your sustainable pace is faster, which means all your higher-intensity efforts can be built upon this stronger foundation.
When you increase the parameter, watch how the curve becomes more pronounced at shorter durations. A higher means you can run much further using your anaerobic system, which translates to better performance in shorter, more intense efforts.
The physiology behind the model
If you only remember one thing from this entire post, make it this section.
The critical speed model reveals insights about how your body’s energy systems operate during different intensities of exercise. At speeds below your critical speed, your body maintains what exercise physiologists call “metabolic equilibrium”. Your heart rate finds a steady rhythm, your breathing settles into a sustainable pattern, and your energy production systems can keep pace with the demands you’re placing on them. Most importantly, blood lactate levels remain stable, and you’re primarily relying on aerobic energy pathways that can theoretically continue indefinitely.
This is why you can maintain paces below critical speed for extended periods. Your body is in a true steady state. VO2 (oxygen consumption) stabilises, somewhere below your VO2max, and your muscles are efficiently using oxygen to produce ATP through aerobic metabolism (via fats or sugars). This is not to say that there’s no anaerobic respiration at these speeds. There is. It’s just that the metabolic byproducts produced at this intensity can be cleared as quickly as they’re produced, preventing the accumulation that leads to fatigue.
Above critical speed, the physiological picture changes dramatically. You begin accumulating metabolic byproducts faster than your body can clear them, blood lactate starts rising progressively and muscle pH starts dropping8 This is what people usually mean by “lactic acid” building up. Lactate itself isn’t the problem; your muscles and heart burn it as fuel. The acidity comes from hydrogen ions released as your muscles turn over energy faster than the aerobic system can keep up. Those ions, along with inorganic phosphate, interfere with your muscles’ ability to contract.. Your VO2 continues to rise toward its maximum. You’re now operating in a metabolically unsustainable state.
This is the important thing to recognise with anaerobic metabolism. When running above critical speed, you don’t need to stop because you run out of energy. You must stop because the build up of metabolic byproducts leads to exhaustion. After reaching exhaustion, if you stop for a few minutes, your muscles will recover and you can go again!
If we graph aerobic and anaerobic contribution against duration, we see a curve that mirrors the critical speed graph — a relationship that aligns perfectly with our understanding of critical speed:
- For very short events like the 100m, the aerobic system barely has time to activate before the race ends, making anaerobic contribution dominant.
- As duration increases, the anaerobic contribution becomes progressively smaller in percentage terms, not because less is used, but because the aerobic contribution grows substantially larger.
AerobicAnaerobic
The graph above and the critical speed model assumes an all-out effort and uniform pace throughout. However, race strategy can significantly impact this, potentially to your advantage9 Jakob Ingebrigtsen often runs the first 8–9 laps of a 5km conservatively, then races the end like a 1500m. If the early laps are below his critical speed, his whole is still there when he winds it up. It only works because his critical speed is higher than everyone else’s..
What surprised me when I first learned about critical speed was how small typically is. I had always assumed that anaerobic energy played a much larger role in running performance, but the data consistently shows that this finite reserve is relatively modest compared to our aerobic capacity. This small value tells us something profound about human physiology — we’re primarily aerobic creatures, with our anaerobic system serving as a limited but powerful backup system.
Differences between athletes
Individual differences in and become apparent when comparing athletes. Consider two runners with similar overall performance but different physiological profiles. One might have a lower but a higher , making them naturally suited to shorter, more explosive efforts like 800m or 1500m races where the anaerobic contribution is significant. Their training would need to focus heavily on developing their aerobic base to raise their critical speed.
Another athlete might have a higher but lower , excelling at longer, steady-state efforts like 5km or 10km races where aerobic capacity dominates. Their training might emphasise developing power and anaerobic capacity to improve their finishing kick and ability to handle pace changes.
Training with critical speed
Again, it’s important to note that is not a training pace. It’s a boundary. Training exactly at isn’t ideal because you’ll likely oscillate between sustainable and unsustainable states due to the inherent error in estimating it. Instead, you should train either some percentage above or below depending on your goals.
Recent research has determined that training at any pace above your results in an unsustainable metabolic state. Therefore, to improve your anaerobic system you don’t need a specific training pace, any range above will do.
How far above or below, and for how long, is the subject of part 4.
Limitations
The model predicts you can run indefinitely at and infinitely fast at very short durations! This is obviously false. Exercise physiologists therefore recommend using the model only for durations between 2 to 30 minutes.
It also ignores heat, altitude, terrain10 When estimating critical speed from training data, feeding the model an effort-adjusted pace allows for hills, and potentially wind and surface too. and how tired you are. Other models, such as Riegel’s power law and omni-duration models, can predict some race times better, but without the physiological grounding that makes critical speed useful. Parts 5 and 6 cover the trade-offs and the alternatives.
Next up: the physiology behind the model.